Conflict and unity: The paradox of Catholic Vietnam


By Sr. Maria Thuan Nguyen, The Catholic World Report



The call to love one’s heritage permeates the childhood of many Vietnamese-American Catholics. However, many historical accounts of the Catholic Church in Vietnam suggest a contradiction between being both a Catholic and a Vietnamese patriot. For example, biographies written by nineteenth-century missionaries portray Vietnamese Catholics as “victims of a pagan nation” who supported French rule. In his book Catholic Vietnam: A Church from Empire to Nation, Charles Keith, an Assistant Professor of History at Michigan State, debunks this reductionist model and astutely shows how the rise and fall of French colonialism, along with ecclesiastical and cultural factors, shaped the history of Catholicism in Vietnam.







catholic vietnam




Left: The sun sets over a Catholic church in Vietnam’s northern Ninh Binh province in this December 2013 photo (CNS photo/Kham, Reuters). Right: The cover of “Catholic Vietnam: A Church from Empire to Nation” by Charles Keith.


Keith’s exemplary scholarship shines through in his overview of how missionary and colonial expansion shaped Vietnamese Catholics’ relationships with other political forces. The emperors who governed Vietnam during the nineteenth-century viewed Catholicism as a Western import that undermined the foundations of Vietnamese hierarchy and society. Furthermore, some Vietnamese viewed Catholicism as inherently opposed to what it meant to be Vietnamese. This led to the destruction of Church property and violence towards priests and catechists, which Keith calls “communitarian conflict.”Increased French control over Vietnam in the late nineteenth-century further intensified communitarian conflicts and anti-French sentiments, resulting in the martyrdom of several thousand Catholics in 1885.


While Vietnamese Catholics venerated the martyrs, Keith rightly points out that this does not translate to Vietnamese Catholics supporting French colonialism. “Ruptures of French rule,” Keith explains, “led many Vietnamese—Catholics and others—to question long-standing social norms and forms of authority.” Also, some of the new missionaries’ immoral conduct and condescending treatment led many Vietnamese Catholics to undermine missionary authority, further straining the relationships between Vietnamese Catholics, French rulers, and French missionaries. According to Keith, the Vietnamese Catholics’ compounded animosity towards the French nurtured a desire for both a national Church and an autonomous nation.


One of the innovative aspects of Catholic Vietnam is Keith’s attempt to analyze the relationship between religion and politics. He points out that despite previous communitarian conflicts, Vietnamese Catholics, for the most part, saw no contradiction between being both a Catholic and a nationalist. Prominent twentieth-century Catholic leaders such as Nguyễn Hữu BÀi sought to strengthen Vietnam’s ties to Rome, and he and his friend Ngô Đình Khả (father of Ngô Đình Diệm, the first president of the Republic of Vietnam) displayed fervent loyalty to the Vietnamese monarchy. However, Keith seems to minimize how the Catholic faith pervaded these leaders’ actions. While he briefly discusses Nguyễn Hữu BÀi’s support of Marian devotions, Keith does not seem to recognize how both BÀi and Khả’s religious beliefs were the driving force behind their political motivations. Following in the Vietnamese martyrs’ footsteps, BÀi and Khả’s fidelity to their Christian faith took primacy over everything else. They zealously worked towards an autonomous Vietnam because they believed it to be God’s will for the Vietnamese people. Keith’s analysis does not fully take into account that for BÀi and Khả, as well as some other prominent Catholic leaders, following in the footsteps of the martyrs meant being patriots. Their political motivations were certainly important, but their Christian faith was the foundation for their political action. Keith’s understatement of this renders an incomplete examination of the connection between religion and politics.


In the second half of his book, Keith further explores how the emergence of a national Church led to an abundant support for national independence. In 1933, Nguyễn BÁ Tòng was ordained as the first bishop of Vietnam, marking a turning point for Vietnamese Catholics. The Catholic Church in Vietnam was transitioning from being a French Catholic mission to becoming a national Church. This cultivated nationalistic attitudes in both Vietnamese Catholics and non-Catholics. To the dismay of French colonialists and missionaries, prominent Catholic intellectuals contributed to the nationalist movement by publishing opinion pieces regarding different notions of nationalism. Nevertheless, relationships between Catholics and other nationalists, particularly the Communists, were strained. Many Catholics withdrew their support from the Democratic Republic of Vietnam (established after World War II), further damaging the relationship between Communist leaders and the Church. Ultimately, most Catholics favored Ngô Đình Diệm, a Catholic nationalist who would be the first president of the Republic of Vietnam in 1955. Keith argues, however, that Vietnamese Catholics were far from unified. He explains that many Vietnamese Catholics (as well as non-Catholics) criticized Diệm’s abuses and the corruption in his regime, leading to deep divisions among Vietnamese Catholics. These ruptures and political divisions resulted in a fragmented Church, leaving the question of the Vietnamese Church’s place in its nation’s history unanswered.

Read the full review by Sr. Maria Thuan Nguyen from The Catholic World Report.


Báo Người Việt hoan nghênh quý vị độc giả đóng góp và trao đổi ý kiến. Chúng tôi xin quý vị theo một số quy tắc sau đây:

Tôn trọng sự thật.
Tôn trọng các quan điểm bất đồng.
Dùng ngôn ngữ lễ độ, tương kính.
Không cổ võ độc tài phản dân chủ.
Không cổ động bạo lực và óc kỳ thị.
Không vi phạm đời tư, không mạ lỵ cá nhân cũng như tập thể.

Tòa soạn sẽ từ chối đăng tải các ý kiến không theo những quy tắc trên.

Xin quý vị dùng chữ Việt có đánh dấu đầy đủ. Những thư viết không dấu có thể bị từ chối vì dễ gây hiểu lầm cho người đọc. Tòa soạn có thể hiệu đính lời văn nhưng không thay đổi ý kiến của độc giả, và sẽ không đăng các bức thư chỉ lập lại ý kiến đã nhiều người viết. Việc đăng tải các bức thư không có nghĩa báo Người Việt đồng ý với tác giả.

Mẫu đơn I-601 là gì, phần 1

Tất cả những người làm đơn xin thị thực dù là thị thực để xin đi du lịch, du học, xin chiếu khán di dân... đều bị lệ thuộc vào điều luật 212.

Saudi Arabia làm chủ đa số cổ phiếu Tesla, muốn mua trọn công ty?

Tổng giám đốc điều hành công ty Tesla, ông Elon Musk, hôm Thứ Ba 7 Tháng Tám bất ngờ đưa ra đề nghị mua lại tất cả các cổ phiếu của công ty với giá khoảng $72 tỉ, để đưa công ty

Những Chiếc Lá Rơi (The Fallen Leaves) – Sách Mới

LỜI GIỚI THIỆU Tuyển tập Fallen Leaves (Những Chiếc Lá Rơi) do Yale University xuất bản vào năm 1989, được dùng làm tài liệu cho sinh viên, học sinh khảo cứu về lịch sử và chiến tranh Việt trong giai đoạn khói lửa...

41 tuổi cưới vợ thứ ba 11 tuổi, gây phẫn nộ dư luận Malaysia

Một người đàn ông Malaysia đang gây phẫn nô cả nước vì cưới một thiếu nữ 11 tuổi ở bên kia biên giới phía miền Nam Thái Lan.

Protected: [BV] Dual Encoding Testing (video bandwidth optimization)

This page show how the videos look at different screen size and bit rate setting in Vzaar when uploading videos for encoding.  The goal is to select one of the setting below as the SD setting which Vzaar will...

Cựu giám đốc James Comey: ‘Chính phủ Trump hủy hoại thanh danh FBI’

video
Trong lời phát biểu mở đầu cuộc điều trần hôm Thứ Năm, 8 tháng 6, trước Ủy Ban Tình Báo Thượng Viện, cựu giám đốc FBI James Comey cáo buộc chính phủ của Tổng Thống Trump có hành động phỉ báng cá nhân ông và cơ quan FBI, cũng như nói những điều sai lạc với người dân Mỹ.

Ông Nguyễn Mạnh Cường

Cáo Phó Ông Nguyễn Mạnh Cường
Cáo Phó Ông Nguyễn Mạnh Cường pháp danh Tịnh Minh Phước đã mãn phần ngày 2 tháng 6, 2017. Nhằm ngày 8 tháng 5 năm Đinh Dậu tại Ontario California. Hưởng Dương 59 tuổi